Wednesday 18 January 2017

Ill woman’s baby stillborn after hospital sent her on two-hour ambulance journey

Tim Healy

Published 13/12/2012 | 18:09

Ni Chunchubhair: (Fiona); personal injuries action for damages against the HSE arising from the death of baby Aodh Cotter, High Court, Dublin, (13/12/12)****see Hi Ct story.Pic. shows: Fiona Ni Chunchubhair and her husband, Stephen Cotter of Killarney, Co Kerry leaving court yesterday (Thurs.) on the opening day of the action for damages.(Pic: CourtPix.)
Ni Chunchubhair: (Fiona); personal injuries action for damages against the HSE arising from the death of baby Aodh Cotter, High Court, Dublin, (13/12/12)****see Hi Ct story.Pic. shows: Fiona Ni Chunchubhair and her husband, Stephen Cotter of Killarney, Co Kerry leaving court yesterday (Thurs.) on the opening day of the action for damages.(Pic: CourtPix.)

A HOSPITAL'S decision to send a critically-ill pregnant woman on a two-hour ambulance journey without a blood transfusion on board resulted in her baby being still-born, the High Court heard.

  • Go To








Had the ambulance been equipped with the blood and staff to administer it, dentist Fiona Ni Chonchubhair's second child Aodh would have survived and she herself would not have suffered the shock, trauma and anger that resulted from the death of her baby, the court also heard.



When the ambulance, sent from Kerry General Hospital in Tralee on a 71-mile trip to Cork Regional Hospital, arrived with Ms Ni Chonchubhair (36), who was nearly 32 weeks’ pregnant and bleeding internally, it took another 15 to 20 minutes for the crew to locate the accident and emergency unit, the court also heard.



Ms Ni Chonchubhair, Countess Road, Killarney, Co Kerry, was operated on and received six units of blood to replace what she had lost, but it was too late for the baby who was delivered stillborn by emergency caesarean section on May 16, 2009.



Yesterday, on the opening day of Ms Ni Chonchubhair's action against the HSE over negligence and breach of duty, counsel for the HSE Emily Egan offered her client's apologies for what had happened to her and her husband Stephen Cotter.



Liability was admitted and the case is before Mr Justice Sean Ryan for assessment of damages.



The court heard the HSE had carried out an internal review of what happened to Ms Ni Conchubhair and made 12 recommendations to ensure it would not recur. However, she told the court she lacked any confidence that the recommendations would be followed.



In her action, Ms Ni Conchubhair, who gave up her job as a dentist and is now a full-time mother of three with another baby on the way, is claiming damages for severe personal injury and personal shock.



She claims that arising out of her experience, she continues to experience flashbacks of the trauma she underwent and has intermittent outbursts of anger, emotional detachment, broken sleep, poor concentration and loss of interest.



She experiences anger towards the hospital and feelings that what had happened should never have happened, her counsel Eugene Gleeson told the court.



Had she received a transfusion en route, she would have suffered a less severe level of hypovolaemic shock which resulted in the baby not getting enough oxygen, he said.



It was their case that there was a "tragedy of errors" which began with the decision to transfer a criticially ill woman to another hospital in an ambulance which did not have cross-matched blood on board, compounded by a 20-minute delay in finding accident and emergency, counsel said.



Ms Ni Conchhubhair told the court she became so anxious to avoid a repetition of what happened that in her two last pregnancies, that for the last three months of each, she rented a house in Cork to make sure she would be near Cork Regional and not Kerry General.



Her husband Stephen, an orthodontist, told Mr Justice Ryan that as health professionals, their confidence in general had been "shattered" by the experience.



It was left to him to break the news of Aodh's death to his wife. He said he brought the baby in and asked Fiona what she wanted to call him. "There was a couple of names and she said Aodh," he said.



But, he said, his wife "was a shell, she was white and spaced out and when she saw Aodh, she could not understand it, it was disbelief that he was taken away."



Before this had happened, Fiona was a happy-go-lucky person but subsequently she gave up socialising and did not like to go out, particularly around Tralee where she felt she might meet doctors and midwives, he said.



The hearing continues.

Read More

Promoted articles

Editor's Choice

Also in Irish News