Shia LaBeouf apologises for plagiarising cartoonist's story - but did he plagiarise apology too?
Published 17/12/2013 | 20:47
SHIA LaBeouf has found himself in trouble after failing to credit an author as the inspiration behind his Cannes Film Festival short film hit, HowardCantour.com.
The actor’s film was released on Vimeo earlier this week, only for its plot and dialogue to be revealed as heavily plagiarised from cartoonist Daniel Clowes’ story about a conflicted film critic, Justin M. Damiano. The film has since been replaced on Vimeo with a 20-second trailer.
The opening monologue of LaBeouf’s 11-minute film is identical to that of Clowes’ work, but the similarities do not end there.
Clowes told BuzzFeed of his shock at seeing LaBeouf pass off a script and many visuals as original work. “I actually can’t imagine what was going through his mind,” the angered author said.
Soon afterwards, the Transformers actor apologised in a series of tweets, admitting his guilt.
'Copying isn't particularly creative work. Being inspired by someone else's idea to produce something new and different IS creative work.'
LaBeouf closed his apology with a simple, “I f***ed up”.
This is not the first time the actor has been accused of plagiarism, after he took blocks of quotes from Tom Chiarella’s Esquire article, “What Is A Man?” and copied them into an email he sent to 30 Rock star Alec Baldwin after a spat.
Interestingly, BuzzFeed have noted that LaBeouf’s Twitter apology closely resembles a message posted four years ago on Yahoo! Answers by a user named Lili.
In response to a question, ‘Why did Picasso say “good artists copy but great artists steal”?’, Lili’s answer reads: “Merely copying isn’t particularly creative work, though it’s useful as training and practice. Being inspired by someone else’s idea to produce something new and different IS creative work.”
Shia LaBeouf has recently finished filming for Lars von Trier's controversially explicit movie Nymphomaniac.
It will debut in Copenhagen on Christmas Day before a likely general UK release in March 2014.
The film's raunchy poster campaign, also directed by Danish director von Trier, shocked in October with its images of the cast pretending to reach sexual climax.
Uma Thurman and Jamie Bell are among the actors portraying orgasmic ecstasy to promote the film, which follows the erotic life of a woman from birth to the age of 50.