'Cutting Edge' review: 'Smart, fast-moving, amusing, even a little moving on occasion - welcome back Brendan O'Connor'
When Brendan O’Connor’s Saturday night chat-show was cancelled last year, there was a strong, very understandable backlash from press and public.
Whether you liked that programme or not, he had come close to matching the viewing figures of previous-day rival The Late Late – on one famous occasion, even taking top spot in the ratings – on a fraction of the budget or star wattage. Essentially, O’Connor (and his team) did it all by himself.
People were tuning in for him, often in spite of the Z-list guests the show had managed to get. He brought something different to a stale format – a spikier and more playful personality, a good sense of humour, and a surprisingly sensitive touch when addressing “difficult” subjects. And the viewers clearly liked it.
So why drop him? The decision didn’t, and still doesn’t, make much sense to me. It was compounded by the fact that O’Connor’s replacement, Ray D’Arcy’s chat-show, was basically the same thing but, so far anyway, not as good.
Anyway. The Corkman belatedly returned to our screens tonight with Brendan O’Connor’s Cutting Edge, as a news-driven panel show. “A newshound, a comedian and someone from the world of sport, media, business or the arts” aiming to knock some crack out of the week’s news – and hopefully make us think too.
I was expecting something akin to Have I Got News For You. This turned out to be more like Tonight with Vincent Browne, although with one huge difference: unlike that show, which is usually an unbearable cacophony of squawking morons and pinched-mouthed know-it-alls, Cutting Edge was quite enjoyable.
They had a semi-decent heavy metal riff for the theme tune, which was a good start. Guests tonight were comedian/actor/professional Tipp man Pat Shortt, Newstalk’s Chris O’Donoghue and businesswoman Norah Casey.
The show is metred out into different sections, as they review the week: “Who’s on the slab”, “Signs of Life”, “Donor Card”, “Weight of Brain”. This was a bit high-concept and muddled for me, I’m afraid; I didn’t always get the connection between the different sections’ titles and their content…I am a bit slow, in fairness.
The chat was lively, though: intelligent without being pompous, funny without trying too hard. O’Connor steered it all with a steady hand; he seems to have that sixth-sense as to when the host should step in and when they should let the talk flow. Plus, unlike many TV presenters, he actually has a functioning personality and sense of humour – always helps in light entertainment, I find.
They covered internet bullying of Sinead O’Connor, mental health, Alan Kelly, Donald Trump, Eurovision, special bags for wine – how bourgeois – smokers’ rights, online dating, nudist beaches and, God spare us, selfie rooms in coffee shops.
- RTE stars have all wished me luck for new show - except Ray D'Arcy - Brendan O'Connor
- Revealed: Behind the scenes on Brendan O'Connor's new RTE show 'The Cutting Edge'
- Still goading himself with a very sharp stick - Brendan O'Connor is back on our screens
We also had the views of some taxi-driver, a daft but fun audience interaction bit, George Hook giving an unexpectedly moving little spiel about loss and life after death, and intermittent sight gags e.g. Putin rolling out the tanks after Ukraine won Eurovision. These were as lame as O’Connor’s jokes used to be on the chat-show, though I suspect that may be the point.
Overall, Cutting Edge is not bad at all. The show settled into its groove right from the jump – a rarity in television, in my experience – and was smart, fast-moving, amusing, even a little moving on occasion.
I think much of its success will depend on the guests each week. Tonight’s panel were all solid operators; bring on three bores and the programme will be boring. Or worse, it’ll devolve into an unbearable cacophony of squawking morons and pinched-mouthed know-it-alls. Shudder.
But a good start for sure, and Cutting Edge will surely get better as they find their feet. Welcome back, Brendan O’Connor.
Really enjoying #CuttingEdge Relaxed format and good discussion. Welcome addition to RTE schedule.— Catherine Halloran (@popcornhack) May 18, 2016
Have to say, I'm liking #CuttingEdge. O'Connor has a real bla'guard's glint to his eye.— Donal O'Keeffe (@Donal_OKeeffe) May 18, 2016
What was the viewer supposed to get from the "who do you think you saw" segment??? #CuttingEdge— JT (@JohnnyTrimble) May 18, 2016
Independent.ie Comments Facility
INM has taken the decision to remove the commenting facility on its online platform Independent.ie to minimise the legal risk to our business that arises from Ireland's draconian libel awards system.
We continue to look forward to receiving comments through direct email contact or via social media, some of which may still be featured on the website Independent.ie