Former Lehman Brothers chairman not liable to employees over stock losses, US appeals court rules
Published 20/03/2016 | 02:30
Richard Fuld, the former chief executive officer of Lehman Brothers Holdings, is not liable to onetime employees who suffered millions of dollars in losses in company stock as the bank descended into bankruptcy, a US federal appeals court has ruled.
By a 3-0 vote, the 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan said Fuld and a Lehman benefit committee were not legally at fault for letting employees participate in an employee stock ownership plan that invested in company stock.
Friday's decision upheld a July 2015 ruling and could end one of the last lawsuits stemming from Lehman's September 2008 collapse.
The Lehman plaintiffs lost despite a 2014 US Supreme Court decision involving Fifth Third Bancorp that lessened the defences available to banks in similar cases.
Daniel Krasner, a lawyer for the employees, and Fuld's lawyer, Todd Fishman, did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Jonathan Youngwood, a lawyer representing benefit committee members, said the ruling "confirms that fiduciaries are not responsible for market and other forces beyond their control."
Lehman workers sued under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, a law invoked when the prices of stocks included in corporate plans plunge. The employees said Lehman's benefit committee breached its duty of prudence by letting them invest in Lehman stock, while Fuld hid the imminence of the Wall Street bank's demise.
But the appeals court said there had been a "cacophony of mixed signals" from investors, credit rating agencies, analysts and media about Lehman, and committee members were not at fault for "failing to recognise the imminence of Lehman's collapse."
Fuld, meanwhile, had no duty under ERISA to apprise the committee of material, nonpublic information about the soundness of Lehman stock, the court added. Other director defendants were dismissed from the case in December 2014.
Lehman's Chapter 11 filing helped trigger the 2008 global financial crisis. Its bankruptcy is the largest in US history.
Sunday Indo Business