Turkey's Twitter ban backfires
Published 21/03/2014 | 20:54
Turkey's attempt to block access to Twitter appears to have backfired with many tech-savvy users circumventing the ban and suspicions growing that the prime minister was using court orders to suppress corruption allegations against him and his government.
Turkey's telecommunications authority said it had blocked access to the social media network hours after Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan threatened to "rip out the roots" of the website.
Tweets have proliferated with links to recordings that appear to incriminate him and other top officials in corruption.
Turkey in the past has blocked access to YouTube, but this is the first ban on Twitter, which is hugely popular in the country - to the point where Turkish hashtags routinely appear in global trends. The social network was instrumental in organising flash protests against the government last year.
By midday, tweets were continuing unabated as users swapped instructions online on how to change settings. One enterprising user spread the word by defacing Turkish election posters with instructions on beating censors.
President Abdullah Gul was among those who circumvented the order, which he contested in a series of tweets. Mr Gul, once a political ally of Mr Erdogan, has spoken out against internet censorship in the past, although last month he approved government moves to tighten controls over the internet.
"I hope this implementation won't last long," he wrote.
Links to leaked recordings have been popping up on two Turkish Twitter accounts, including one in which a voice resembling Mr Erdogan's instructs his son to dispose of large amounts of cash from a residence amid a police graft investigation.
Mr Erdogan, who denies corruption, said the recording was fabricated and part of a plot by followers of an influential US-based Muslim cleric to discredit the government before March 30 local elections.
Mr Erdogan has cast the elections as a referendum on his rule.
"Prime Minister Erdogan's move spells the lengths he will go to censor the flood of politically damaging wiretap recordings circulating on social media," said Emma Sinclair-Webb, senior Turkey researcher at Human Rights Watch.
Andrew Przybylski, a researcher at Britain's Oxford Internet Institute, said the ban appeared to be working through Domain Name System - or DNS - blocking, which was easy to work around.
He said many Twitter-hungry Turks manually changed the DNS settings on their computers and in their phones to point to Google's Domain Name System, which is not affected by the ban.
Earlier, many users trying to access the network instead saw a notice from Turkey's telecommunications authority, citing four court orders.
Turkey's lawyers' association asked a court to overturn the ban, arguing it was unconstitutional and violated Turkish and European human rights laws. Turkey's main opposition party also applied for a cancellation.
"Turkey now stands along with countries such as North Korea, China, Saudi Arabia, Iran and Russia on Internet freedom," columnist Yavuz Baydar said.
Twitter's @policy account earlier sent out messages telling Turkish users in both English and Turkish they could send out tweets by using short message service, or SMS.
European Commission Vice President Neelie Kroes criticised the Twitter ban in Turkey - a country that is seeking to join the European Union - as "groundless, pointless, cowardly". Other EU officials also voiced concerns.
Lutfi Elvan, Turkey's minister in charge of transport and communications, said Turkey was merely obeying court orders - although an Istanbul lawyers group argued the court decisions were about blocking access to websites deemed to be violating privacy - not the entire website.
The telecommunications authority accused Twitter of violating "personal rights and the confidentiality of private lives" and said access would be restored only when Twitter removes illegal content.
"Turkey is not a country that bans the Internet," Mr Elvan said. "We have to stand together against insults and unlawfulness."
Technology minister Fikri Isik said officials were holding talks with Twitter and that the ban would be lifted if an agreement is reached.
He was quoted as saying that officials are holding talks with Twitter and that the ban will be lifted if some kind of an agreement is reached
The original source of the leaked recordings is unclear. The ban comes amid rumours and news reports that even more damaging recordings are about to emerge.
"Conspiracy or not, limiting freedom of speech is no way for the Turkish government to tackle a political crisis," said Sinclair-Webb of Human Rights Watch.
In Berlin, the German government's human rights commissioner, Christoph Straesser, called on Turkey to reverse the decision immediately, saying "limiting freedom of the press and opinion on this scale is unacceptable".