Monday 5 December 2016

Greece crisis: Greeks blink first with tough tax and pension reform on table

John O'Donnell and George Georgiopoulos

Published 09/07/2015 | 09:29

Members of the European Parliament hold placards which reads "No - Freedom to Greece" ahead of the speech of Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras at the European Parliament in Strasbourg, France, July 8, 2015. Euro zone members have given Greece until the end of the week to come up with a proposal for sweeping reforms in return for loans that will keep the country from crashing out of Europe's currency bloc and into economic ruin. REUTERS/Vincent Kessler
Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras arrives to address the European Parliament in Strasbourg, France, July 8, 2015. Euro zone members have given Greece until the end of the week to come up with a proposal for sweeping reforms in return for loans that will keep the country from crashing out of Europe's currency bloc and into economic ruin. REUTERS/Vincent Kessler
Greek Finance Minister Euclid Tsakalotos waits for the start of the meeting of eurozone finance ministers in Brussels. Photo: AP
A pensioner waits outside a branch of the National Bank to receive part of his pension in Athens yesterday
A pensioner exits a National Bank branch after receiving part of his pension in Athens, Greece July 8, 2015. Euro zone members have given Greece until the end of the week to come up with a proposal for sweeping reforms in return for loans that will keep the country from crashing out of Europe's currency bloc and into economic ruin. REUTERS/Alkis Konstantinidis
People stand in a queue to enter a bank for limited services, as the front page of newspaper depicting the Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras reading ''Time runs out for a solution before catastrophe'', in Athens. Photo: AP
'Short term, Grexit will be traumatic, wiping out the assets of middle-class Greeks'
(L-R) Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte, German Chancellor Angela Merkel, Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras (standing C), Austrian Chancellor Werner Faymann (rear, in red tie), and European Commission President Jean Claude Juncker take part in a euro zone EU leaders emergency summit on the situation in Greece, in Brussels, Belgium, July 7, 2015. Tsipras launched a desperate bid to win fresh aid from sceptical creditors at an emergency euro zone summit on Tuesday, before his country's banks run out of money. REUTERS/Yves Herman
Greek prime minister Alexis Tsipras has addressed the European Parliament (AP)
Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras (L) talks with European Central Bank President Mario Draghi during a euro zone EU leaders emergency summit on the situation in Greece in Brussels, Belgium, July 7, 2015. Greece faces a last chance to stay in the euro zone on Tuesday when Tsipras puts proposals to an emergency euro zone summit after Greek voters resoundingly rejected the austerity terms of a defunct bailout. REUTERS/Yves Herman
People queue at an ATM to withdraw cash in Athens on July 7, 2015. European Commission head Jean-Claude Juncker said that he was against an exit by Greece from the euro, even though Greeks massively rejected bailout terms in a referendum this weekend
Newly-appointed Finance Minister Euclid Tsakalotos (R) and outgoing Yannis Varoufakis embrace at the Finance Ministry after a handover ceremony in Athens
Donations of cash are counted following a collection for the Greek Solidarity Campaign, during a rally in support of Greece at the TUC's Congress House, in London, Britain, July 6, 2015. REUTERS/Peter Nicholls
(L-R) German Chancellor Angela Merkel, Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras, Austrian Chancellor Werner Faymann, European Central Bank President Mario Draghi and European Commission President Jean Claude Juncker take part in a euro zone EU leaders emergency summit on the situation in Greece in Brussels, Belgium, July 7, 2015. Greece faces a last chance to stay in the euro zone on Tuesday when Tsipras puts proposals to an emergency euro zone summit after Greek voters resoundingly rejected the austerity terms of a defunct bailout. REUTERS/Yves Herman
A tourist takes a picture outside the Greek Central Bank
Taoiseach Enda Kenny speaks with British Prime Minister David Cameron during a round table meeting at the EU summit in Brussels
A pensioner waits outside a branch of the National Bank to receive part of his pension in Athens, Greece, July 7, 2015. Greece faces a last chance to stay in the euro zone on Tuesday when Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras puts proposals to an emergency euro zone summit after Greek voters resoundingly rejected the austerity terms of a defunct bailout. REUTERS/Yannis Behrakis
As EU chiefs continue wrangling with a desperate Greek government, the commission said that our bailed-out banks should be allowed to profiteer on the back of mortgage holders
'The leather-clad Greek finance minister failed to endear himself to his eurozone counterparts with his penchant for incendiary comments and brash negotiating tactics'
Pensioners wait to enter a bank as others queue to use the ATMs of the branch in Athens (AP)

Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras raced on Thursday to finalise a tough package with tax hikes and pension reforms due within hours if Athens is to win a new aid lifeline from creditors and avoid crashing out of the euro.

  • Go To

Tsipras was huddled with advisers, pulling together a package of reforms that is expected to include much tougher measures than those included in a previous plan from creditors that was rejected by Greeks in a referendum on Sunday.

But having won wide public support at the referendum and the subsequent backing of opposition parties, an emboldened Tsipras is expected to have an easier time facing down any resistance at home, allowing him to focus to appeasing creditors.

The Greek daily Kathimerini said the package was worth 12 billion euros, bigger than a previous 8 billion euro plan because the economy - battered by two weeks of capital controls - was now expected to shrink 3 percent instead of growing 0.5 percent this year.

A government official, speaking on condition of anonymity, disputed the Kathimerini figure, saying the package was still a work in progress.

The offer must go far enough to satisfy sceptical creditors but may face resistance from the hard-left wing of Tsipras' Syriza party and from his junior coalition partner, the Independent Greeks, after the government campaigned and won a resounding 'No' to more austerity in a referendum on July 5.

In a sign of the some of the upcoming challenges Tsipras will face, the leader of the far-left flank of his Syriza party came out to denounce any imposition of harsh measures on Greeks.

"We don't want add to the past two failed bailouts a third bailout of tough austerity which will not give any prospects for the country," Energy Minister Panagiotis Lafazanis told reporters. "Greece is not facing execution, it is not ready to accept any fait accompli."

But Lafazanis also said it was clear Greece was looking to reach a deal soon with the institutions that will respect the "dignity" of people, leaving the door open for him to eventually back an agreement struck with creditors.

With banks shuttered and the economy grinding to a halt after two weeks of capital controls, Syriza rebels will have a tougher time making their case against any deal with creditors that paves the way for banks to open again.

Greece's European partners want the reforms proposal on the table by Friday and Athens has promised to produce it on Thursday at the latest. If satisfied, the European leaders would endorse the package on Sunday, averting a potential Greek exit from Europe's single currency.

Greece emerged last year from a deep recession that shrank its gross domestic product by a quarter over a six-year period, leaving a quarter of the workforce unemployed.

Government sources said proposed tax hikes would include - an increase in corporate tax to 28 percent from 26 percent; a rise in VAT on luxury goods to 13 from 10 percent; a rise in VAT on processed foods, restaurants, transport and some health services offered by the private sector to 23 from 13 percent and a VAT hike on hotels to 13 percent from 6.5 percent.

Earlier, European Central Bank President Mario Draghi voiced unprecedented doubts about the chances of rescuing Greece from bankruptcy as Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras was due to put forward last-ditch reform proposals on Thursday.

Italian daily Il Sole 24 Ore quoted the ECB chief, under growing fire in Germany for keeping Greek banks afloat, as saying he was not sure a solution would be found for Greece and he did not believe Russia would come to Athens' rescue.

Asked if a deal to save Greece could be wrapped up, Draghi told the paper as he was boarding a plane in Brussels on Wednesday: "I don't know, this time it's really difficult."

The ECB is keeping shuttered Greek banks afloat with emergency liquidity capped until the weekend as leaders of the 19-nation euro zone race to find a last-minute third bailout for Athens.

Asked if he expected Russian President Vladimir Putin to help Greece, Draghi said: "I don't believe so, I don't see it as a real risk ... and then, they don't have money themselves."

The usually discreet central banker was speaking after an emergency euro zone summit on Tuesday gave Greece five days to come up with a credible plan to repair its public finances and reform its economy or face an economic meltdown and possible exit from Europe's common currency.

Under that timetable, the leftist Greek government, which formally applied on Wednesday for a three-year loan from the European Stability Mechanism bailout fund, has until midnight to present convincing, detailed reform proposals.

International Monetary Fund chief Christine Lagarde added a potential complication by insisting that any deal must include a restructuring to make Greece's massive debt pile sustainable.

Speaking in Washington on Wednesday, Lagarde said that to address Greece's acute crisis any deal needed to have two legs. One was structural reforms and fiscal consolidation.

"The other leg is debt restructuring, which we believe is needed in the case of Greece for it to have debt sustainability," she said.

Germany, Athens' biggest creditor, has said any debt write-off would be illegal under the EU treaty and has also taken a restrictive approach to reprofiling Athens' official borrowings to ease the short-term pressure of debt service.

Even France, Greece's strongest support in the euro zone, acknowledged on Thursday it was working on scenarios for a Greek exit from the currency area if weekend efforts to clinch a deal fail.

"We would be irresponsible if we did not consider this question. So we are thinking about it because it's our duty to be ready for any eventuality, but it's not what we want," French Finance Minister Michel Sapin told LCI television.

TSIPRAS SEEKS CONSENSUS

According to the Athens daily Kathimerini, Greece is planning a reform package worth 12 billion euros over two years, more than previously planned to offset a return to recession after months of difficult negotiations with creditors.

Instead of growing by 0.5 percent this year, months of uncertainty and almost two weeks of capital controls mean "there are estimates of a recession of about 3 percent", it said.

"It is estimated that the measures of 8 billion euros that Greece had presented for 2015 and 2016 will have to be increased by 2 billion euros per year, raising the total to 12 billion euros for the two years," Kathimerini reported.

There was no immediate official confirmation of the figures.

Greece last year emerged from a deep recession that shrank its gross domestic product by a quarter over six years.

A second newspaper, Naftemporiki, detailed what it said were proposed tax hikes to raise the money - an increase in corporate tax to 28 percent from 26 percent and in value added tax on luxury goods from to 13 from 10 percent; on processed foods, restaurants, transport and some private health services to 23 from 13 percent and on hotels to 13 percent from 6.5 percent.

The report said Greek islands would continue to enjoy tax breaks that creditors had sought to scrap. Naftemporiki said the entire package would be worth 10 to 12 billion euros.

Such measures may face resistance from the hard-left wing of Tsipras' Syriza party and from his junior coalition partner, the Independent Greeks, after the government won a resounding 'No' to more austerity in a referendum on July 5.

DRAGHI UNDER FIRE

Draghi's support for Greek banks came under attack from German Bundesbank chief Jens Weidmann, a senior ECB policymaker, who said it was up to governments, not the central bank, to provide any aid to Athens.

"Central banks need to show where their limits lie," he told an audience in Frankfurt. "It needs to be crystal clear that responsibility for further developments in Greece ... lies with the Greek government and the countries providing assistance – not the ECB Governing Council."

Weidmann also said capital controls should remain in force in Greece until there was any deal, and that the ECB should not increase its liquidity assistance for Greek banks, without which they may collapse next week.

European officials told Reuters on Wednesday that some large Greek banks may have to be shut and taken over by stronger rivals as part of a restructuring of the sector that would follow any bailout of the country.

One official said Greece's four big banks - National Bank of Greece, Eurobank, Piraeus and Alpha Bank - could be reduced to just two, a measure that would doubtless encounter fierce resistance in Athens.

A second person said that although mergers of banks were necessary, this could happen over the longer term.

"The Greek economy is in ruins. That means the banks need a restart," said the first person, adding that prompt action was necessary following any bailout between Athens and the euro zone. "Cyprus could be a role model."

Greece is preparing a reform package worth €12bn over two years, more than previously planned, in an effort to offset a return to recession after months of negotiations with creditors, the Greek newspaper Kathimerini reported.

Reuters

Read More

Promoted articles

Editors Choice

Also in Business