Germans claim Dublin is no match for Frankfurt for Brexit relocators
Dublin has less office space and higher commercial rents than Frankfurt, making it a less attractive option for business looking to relocate from post-referendum London, a German think tank has claimed.
As European Union countries ramp up efforts to carve up the Brexit spoils from the City of London, the Cologne Institute for Economic Research suggested Dublin is also too far down the global financial centre ranking to be a real competitor.
And it claimed the city wasn't as internationally accessible as both Paris and Frankfurt, the two other locations mooted as potential beneficiaries from post-Brexit financial services investment. The potential loss of 'passporting rights' could see some finance houses move operations out of London.
Dublin has been talked up as a possible contender for some increased investment in the wake of the Brexit vote, despite being of a smaller scale than some other European locations. But there are doubts about the extent to which it can benefit because of a shortage of housing and the high personal tax rates.
Unsurprisingly perhaps, the German think tank believes Frankfurt is "likely to be the main profiteer of Brexit".
"Dublin is only ranked 39 in the global financial centre ranking, which measures financial flows, the number of banks and other financial indicators, and it has also deficits in international accessibility, at least compared to Frankfurt and Paris," the report said.
The report also states that Frankfurt scored strongly in the most recent Mercer Quality of Living Ranking, coming in at seven. That compares with a score of 33 for Dublin and 37 for Paris.
"Of course, quality of living is in particular a question of preferences and without doubt some bankers will prefer Paris and Dublin over Frankfurt, but at least the analysis of Mercer hints at some of the amenities of Frankfurt," the report adds.
Frankfurt, the report states, can attract business which needs knowledge about regulation, as it hosts the European Central Bank and the European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority is located in Frankfurt, while Paris has the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), although this is less relevant for banks.
Dublin, however, is attracting interest.
Insurer Prudential has confirmed it is considering shifting funds from its asset management wing to Dublin and Luxembourg as it moves to deal with the fallout from the UK vote.
The boss of Prudential's M&G fund arm, Anne Richards, said the company could boost the number of funds it already has based in the two cities, depending on the outcome of the Brexit negotiations. And international law firm Pinsent Masons is reportedly looking for office space here.